Herring Shoes Journal

Earlier this year, we celebrated the homecoming of the suit and, in tandem, the return of the black formal shoe. This trend was seen on the catwalks ahead of the autumn/winter 2024/25 season. Well, guess what? That season is upon us!

While we are delighted to see enthusiasm for this beloved shoe genre restored, you do not need to be strict followers of fashion to adopt this style. As countless professionals will tell you, a black formal shoe is a firm favourite as the reliable choice for office footwear.

Even if you do not have a formal dress code at work, black shoes are a requirement for a multitude of occasions, ranging from weddings, funerals and graduations to job interviews and black-tie events. We cannot stress this enough; you will never regret buying a pair of good-quality black formal shoes.

We have selected some of our favourite styles to showcase the fact that the black formal shoe does not have to be boring. They may do the job – especially if you need a boardroom or client meeting-worthy style – but look great because they are classics.

The Oxford cap shoe is widely regarded as the most formal of traditional styles making it a staple of businessmen and professionals. Oxfords are ideal for formal events too as they look good with a dark suit.

The Knightsbridge, for example, is a quintessential black Oxford crafted for us by traditional English shoemakers, Barker. Incorporating the finest calf leathers for the upper, a full leather lining, leather insoles and a Goodyear-welted sole, it has everything you expect from a classic Oxford. Unadorned and unfussy, the Knightsbridge is one of our most popular formal styles.

While a brogue is an iconic shoe design due to the punched holes in the leather, a semi-brogue has less perforations, which can make them feel a little sleeker and more business-like. See What’s the difference between a brogue and a semi-brogue for the full low-down. Our new Morecombe style is a luxurious shoe, featuring a unique punching pattern that uses a semi-circle and two horizontal dots rather than a more traditional circle and two vertical dots. We think this small difference makes this shoe more elegant.

Another style from the Barker factory is the Bishop. We describe this shoe as “a British thoroughbred”. It’s a double monk, so has a pair of buckles, with a thin rubber sole that allows for a sleek, traditional silhouette with the benefit of added durability. Made on the classic 386 last, this also provides an elegant shape and good fitting qualities and comfort.

Lastly, for a more American Ivy League or Amalfi Coast vibe made by another British factory, the Ascot II is a wonderfully classic loafer. A versatile shoe for work and play, team this loafer with black or dark socks for days in the office or go for bare ankles for drinks after work.

In short, all these styles will see you through this latest love affair with the suit but will also see you right for work and formal occasions.